Home / About Donn
About the agency ยท Portage, Michigan

Meet Donn Carlisle.

EverSafe Insurance is an independent agency in Portage, Michigan, owned by Donn Carlisle, a licensed Michigan insurance agent. Donn built it so he could compare options from several insurance companies for his clients, instead of offering just one.

Donn Carlisle with his dog Archie
Donn Carlisle with Archie, the EverSafe office dog.
Our mission

Our mission is to put you, not an insurance company, at the center of every decision. We shop the market, explain your choices in plain language, and stay with you as your life and business grow.

Why Donn opened an independent agency

An agent who represents a single insurance company can only offer that company's policy, even when it is not the best fit for the person across the desk. Donn opened EverSafe as an independent agency so he could look at options from several insurance companies, explain the differences in plain language, and let clients choose.

That means you get more than one take-it-or-leave-it number. You get a side-by-side look at limits, deductibles, and exclusions, and an honest answer when a policy does not fit.

Experience

Donn brings 10+ years of insurance experience to EverSafe, helping families, first-time homeowners, renters, and small businesses across Southwest Michigan.

A personal note from Donn

After more than 10 years with a large insurance company, I saw how often clients were limited to a single company's prices and coverage options. I started Eversafe Insurance to change that. As an independent agency, we can compare options from multiple insurance companies and find the coverage that truly fits you, whether you're protecting your family, your first home, or your business.

What working with EverSafe looks like

  • You talk to the agent. Calls and questions come to Donn's desk, not a national call center.
  • More than one option. As an independent agency, EverSafe compares coverage from multiple insurance companies.
  • Plain language. Deductibles, exclusions, and Michigan no-fault choices explained before you buy.
  • No invented savings. Price follows the risk and the insurance company. The goal is a fair comparison and a policy you understand.
  • Local. Portage-based, serving Portage, Kalamazoo, and all of Southwest Michigan.

Coverage Donn can help with

Auto insurance, home insurance, renters insurance, business insurance, and life insurance.

Licensing. Donn Carlisle Agency LLC, doing business as EverSafe Insurance. Michigan agency license 0766261. NPN 17922253.

Get in touch

Have a question about your coverage?

Call (269) 256-4746, Monday to Friday, 8 to 4, email donn@eversafeinsurancemi.com, or send the quote form.